A review of Sin And Bones

Sin And Bones

Review by BlkScript Published November 14, 2026

Synopsis

When a successful music executive falls into a passionate affair with a younger mechanic and aspiring saxophonist, their undeniable chemistry becomes a complicated game of love, power, and ambition, where both discover that what they want from each other may be dangerously different.

Critic Score
★★★★★ 5.0
Audience Score
★★★★★ 5.0
(8 ratings)

Cast

Crew

Tags

14 responses to “Sin And Bones”

  1. Man listen, Saint deserved so much better lol. I was really rooting for that man the whole movie. And don’t get me wrong, Brooke was fine as hell, like FINE fine, but she had me irritated with how she was treating him. I get where she was coming from on some things but damn, you can’t expect somebody to keep showing up for you when you only want them around on your terms. What I really liked about this movie though is neither one of them was completely right or wrong. They both wanted something from each other and neither knew how to just be honest about it. The dude who played Saint did a great job, especially in those moments where he wasn’t even saying much. You could see everything on his face. And the actress playing Brooke? Yeah she killed that role too because I was mad at her one minute and actually feeling bad for her the next. Their chemistry was crazy too. This was a really good film and I love that it didn’t try to make everything some fairytale love story. Sometimes two people can have all the chemistry in the world and still not be good for each other. Definitely worth watching. And I’m still Team Saint lol.

  2. Okay so I’ve officially watched Sin and Bones twice now and I actually loved it even more the second time. First of all, can we talk about how refreshing it was to see the roles reversed for once?! We’re so used to seeing successful men dealing with women who want more from them emotionally, and here we have a woman who has worked her entire life to build something for herself and isn’t willing to compromise that. And I’m sorry but I’m defending Brooke on this one. Was she perfect? Absolutely not. But I understood her. Women are constantly expected to sacrifice, nurture, accommodate and make room for everybody else’s feelings. Brooke knew what she wanted and I don’t think that makes her a villain. Saint was a good man, no question, but being a good man doesn’t automatically mean a woman owes you the relationship you want. Now I will say she could’ve handled certain things differently, but I appreciated that the film allowed her to be complicated without making her some horrible person. Nolita Pore was EXCELLENT. The way she carried herself, her delivery, even the moments where you could see Brooke struggling to keep it together. Just beautiful acting. And DeVon Lamont Thomas was equally amazing. Their chemistry felt so natural and believable. I watched it again because I wanted to catch the things I missed the first time and there were definitely moments that hit differently. Such a beautifully done film and honestly one of the more interesting relationship stories I’ve watched in a while. Great job for an independent production.

  3. Good Morning!

    Bravo to the cast and crew of this production! I’ve been a member of BLKScript for quite some time, and I watch nearly everything the platform releases. It’s become one of my favorite places to discover independent films, so I was looking forward to Sin and Bones. I got around to watching it while preparing breakfast, and I enjoyed it quite a bit. What surprised me most was how much of the film deals with pride. Not just romantic pride, but the kind that keeps people from admitting what they need because they’re afraid of what that admission might cost them.

    One thing I found particularly interesting was how differently Brooke and Saint seemed to understand the relationship they were in. I actually found myself questioning whether either of them had been completely honest about their intentions from the beginning. Brooke certainly has her issues, but I didn’t interpret her behavior as simply being selfish. I saw a woman who has worked incredibly hard to build a life for herself and has become accustomed to protecting it. Saint, on the other hand, seems to believe that his feelings and ambitions should be understood without always having to explain them. That disconnect was fascinating to watch, especially because the film doesn’t give us a convenient person to blame.

    I also want to mention how much I enjoyed the casting. Nolita has a commanding screen presence. There’s something about the way she carries herself that makes Brooke’s professional success believable before we even know much about her career. Devon was a pleasant surprise for me. He has a very watchable quality and a charisma. I especially appreciated the way the film incorporated his relationship with music. It gave the character an identity beyond being someone’s romantic interest.

    My biggest criticism would probably be the supporting characters. I thought there were opportunities to make Brooke and Saint’s respective worlds feel a little more populated. Even one or two additional interactions outside their relationship might have given us another perspective on who these people are when they’re not together.

    My hero take away was the ending. Not only was that so beautifully executed but after the ending,I found myself reconsidering certain scenes afterward. But seriously, the rewind effect going back into the saxophone was cinematic genius!!! It was beautiful and the scoring was just perfection.

    Having watched all of Blake Martin’s films on this platform, I think Sin and Bones represents a significant turning point in his development as a director. On Hold had an interesting premise, M.A.I.D. showed an improvement in his handling of tension, and Alone, Now demonstrated his willingness to explore difficult emotional territory. But this film feels like the first time he’s really beginning to understand how to use the entire frame to communicate something. His compositions feel more intentional, the environments have more personality, and there’s a stronger relationship between the cinematography and the material. It’s remarkable to consider that these four films were released within such a short period.

    I would also argue that Blake is becoming more comfortable allowing his actors to carry the material rather than relying so heavily on the writing. That’s an important distinction, and one I hope he continues to explore. There are still areas where his filmmaking could benefit from greater subtlety, but the improvement from his first film to this one is impossible to ignore. And to be clear, thats not a dig at Blake. I have that some critique for large scale directors. I think every director sometimes gives us things that could be subtle.

    What I ultimately took away from Sin and Bones was a question about the difference between loving someone and making room for them in your life. Those aren’t necessarily the same thing, and I thought the film explored that distinction in a way that felt relevant, particularly for adults who have already established careers, expectations, and certain ideas about what a relationship should look like.

    I’m glad BLKScript continues to provide a home for films like this. I would much rather spend my time watching an independent filmmaker take interesting creative risks than watch another polished production that has absolutely nothing to say. Sin and Bones gave me plenty to think about, and I would recommend it, especially to anyone who enjoys relationship dramas that invite conversation after the credits roll.

    Again, Bravo to all involved.

  4. I watched Sin and Bones and my first question when it ended was WHO DO I NEED TO TALK TO ABOUT MAKING THIS A FULL MOVIE? This was good. Like really good. And I think my biggest complaint is that it ended right when I felt like I was getting into everybody’s business. I wanted to know more about Saint’s life, his music, how he ended up in that garage, and what his plans were before Brooke came along. And Brooke? I need to meet some of her friends because I KNOW somebody in her circle has been telling her about herself for years 😂. But that’s what made the movie interesting to me. These weren’t people who needed some big dramatic tragedy to create problems. They were doing a perfectly good job creating their own. I also liked that the movie touched on something men don’t always talk about, which is how uncomfortable it can be when somebody has the ability to change your life financially or professionally, especially when you’re sleeping with that person. That’s a whole different kind of pressure. And I think there’s a much bigger story to tell there. The actors did a great job making me interested in what happened to these people, and I would absolutely watch them again in a longer version. As far as Blake Martin’s next film, I would love to see him tackle something completely outside of the relationship drama space. Give me a thriller, a crime story, something with a little danger and some unexpected turns. I think he has the imagination for it, and I’d like to see what he does when the stakes are bigger than somebody getting their heart broken. But please don’t abandon Sin and Bones either. I genuinely think there’s a feature film here, and I hope somebody with some money and good sense recognizes that. Because I have questions, and 20 minutes was not enough time for y’all to answer them. Lol. Great job to everybody involved. This one was worth my Sunday afternoon.

  5. First of all, I really liked this movie, but I need everybody to stop discussing Brooke and Saint like this was simply a relationship that didn’t work out. Because what I watched was two people operating from completely different survival mechanisms and calling it intimacy. Let’s start with Brooke because I feel like people are going to misunderstand her the most. Brooke has spent so much of her adult life being valued for what she can accomplish, what she can provide, and what she represents that I genuinely don’t think she knows how to exist in a relationship where she isn’t managing the outcome. Her money isn’t the issue. Her inability to separate generosity from control is. And before anybody calls her manipulative, I think we need to acknowledge how women, particularly successful Black women, are conditioned to believe that being needed is the closest thing they’ll ever get to being loved. Now Saint? Baby, we need to unpack him too. Because I think Saint was attracted to Brooke’s world just as much as he was attracted to Brooke herself, and that’s not necessarily a bad thing. But I also think he was carrying some resentment about the very power dynamic he was benefiting from. He wanted to be seen as her equal while simultaneously hoping her connections could open doors for him. And there’s nothing wrong with wanting access, but we have to be honest about what we’re bringing into relationships. What really got me was how both of them seemed to have these unspoken expectations and then punished each other for not meeting them. That’s not communication. That’s two people expecting emotional reimbursement for investments nobody agreed to make. And can we talk about how class shows up in romantic relationships? Because we love to pretend money doesn’t change how people interact, but it absolutely does. Brooke’s financial independence gives her the freedom to define the relationship on her terms, while Saint’s financial position makes every gift, every opportunity, and every disagreement carry a different meaning. That’s not just romance. That’s economics, gender expectations, and social conditioning all sitting at the same dinner table. I will say I wish the film had explored back story more. But maybe that’s the point. We don’t always get a complete psychological profile of the people who hurt us. Sometimes we just experience them. I also want to give Blake Martin credit for writing a story that made me examine my own assumptions about who deserves sympathy. I caught myself extending grace to Brooke in situations where I probably would have judged a man much more harshly, and that made me uncomfortable in a productive way. Anyway, I enjoyed this film, but I need everybody involved to go to therapy, separately, before they even THINK about dating another person. And somebody please check on Saint because that man is going to write an entire jazz album about this experience. 😂

  6. I’m convinced some of y’all watched a completely different movie than I did because the way people are carrying on about Brooke is hilarious to me. I ran to the comments because I just knew somebody was going to be mad at that woman. And sure enough, there they were. Meanwhile, I’m sitting on my couch thinking Brooke might be the only person in this entire situation with some sense. And can we please discuss how Saint made up their entire chemistry in his head? Sir, when did we get to this part of the relationship? Because I must have missed the meeting where everybody agreed we were building a life together. That man was moving like he had already picked out his side of the closet. I nearly fell off my couch. And then the music business situation? Oh, that would’ve sent me over the edge. Because now I’m wondering if you like me or if you like the fact that I know people who can listen to your demo. I don’t know about the rest of you, but I have worked too hard to get where I am to have somebody playing games with my livelihood. And the funniest part is Brooke probably went to work the next morning, answered 47 emails, approved somebody’s album budget, and ordered lunch like nothing happened. That’s the kind of petty I aspire to be. I really enjoyed this movie though. The clothes, the locations, even that garage. I also liked that Brooke was allowed to be a little arrogant. Women like her exist, and quite frankly, some of them have earned the right to be. The actress playing her had me cracking up with some of those facial expressions because I knew exactly what she was thinking. And I have to give the director credit for that whole situation with the flowers. That was a nice little touch. I won’t spoil it for anybody who hasn’t watched yet, but I appreciated the humor in that moment. My sister and I have been arguing about this movie all morning. She’s feeling sorry for Saint, and I’m trying to figure out why she’s always volunteering to be somebody’s emotional support department. Anyway, I had a good time watching this. I’d definitely watch another movie about Brooke, preferably one where she takes a vacation, meets a handsome stranger, and doesn’t tell him a single thing about what she does for a living. Let that man think she works at the post office. See how that goes.

  7. Blake, you did it AGAIN! I’m always in awe of your ability to tell stories that challenge perspectives, push boundaries, and spark meaningful conversations. I especially love how you continue to give us refreshing, layered portrayals of Black love and relationships that challenge the narratives we’re so accustomed to seeing on screen. Devon Thomas and Nolita Poor were phenomenal, and the chemistry was jumping right off the screen! The storytelling, the performances, the complexities of the characters—EVERYTHING was so well done. Flowers to you and everyone who played a part in bringing this story to life. Truly phenomenal work, and I cannot wait to see what you create next!

  8. I’m a licensed therapist, and one of the first things I learned in this profession is that people can give you a very accurate account of what happened and still have absolutely no understanding of their own role in it. That’s what kept coming to mind while watching this. I enjoyed this film much more than I expected to, mostly because I kept changing my mind about what I was witnessing. About halfway through, I actually stopped the movie to get something to drink and realized I’d been sitting there analyzing two fictional people like they had appointments with me on Monday.
    What interested me about Saint was his relationship with disappointment. He seemed to experience certain setbacks as confirmation of something much bigger about himself. That’s an exhausting way to live, because suddenly you’re not just responding to what happened yesterday. You’re responding to every other time life made you feel small. I would be curious to know how often he allows himself to celebrate what he’s accomplished without immediately comparing it to where he thinks he should be. There’s a difference between being ambitious and being unable to tolerate your current circumstances. I suspect Saint struggles with that distinction.
    Brooke interested me for an entirely different reason. I kept wondering what she does when she makes a mistake that can’t be corrected with intelligence, preparation, or hard work. Some people become so good at solving problems that they never develop much patience for situations that have no immediate solution. I recognized that tendency in her. I also wondered whether she has people in her life who can tell her she’s wrong without her treating it as a challenge to her judgment. That’s a question I’d genuinely want to explore with her.
    One of the more interesting things about the film was how quickly the meaning of a conversation could change depending on what happened immediately before it. That’s something I see in my work constantly. People will spend twenty minutes arguing about a sentence when the actual injury occurred three days earlier. By the time they’re discussing the current issue, they’re barely responding to each other anymore. They’re responding to their interpretation of everything that came before.
    I did wish the film had given us a better sense of how much time had passed between certain events. From a psychological standpoint, that matters. There were a couple of places where I wasn’t sure how much history I was supposed to assume existed between these characters. And I have to say, the scene involving the music demos was especially interesting to me. Not because of the argument itself, but because of how quickly something deeply personal became ammunition. When someone reveals an insecurity or a private ambition to you, there’s an enormous amount of trust involved. What happens to that information during a conflict can permanently change how safe that person feels around you.
    The performances were convincing enough that I caught myself wondering what each character would say if I interviewed them separately. I suspect I’d hear two stories that barely resembled each other, and both people would be completely sincere. I really enjoyed Sin and Bones. It gave me something to discuss beyond whether the couple should have stayed together. And for the record, neither one of them would be getting relationship advice from me after a single session. We’d have quite a bit of individual work to do first.

    • I posted a second review because I didnt see my first review post this morning but now I do. Maybe a system error? Anywho- glad to have seen this project.

Leave a Reply